No Rules, Just Me

The Problem With Redefining Masculinity

I read a post today titled The Alpha Myth, and something about it bothered me almost immediately. I don't disagree with everything the author says. I agree with a good deal of what he says about confidence, kindness, and emotional maturity. My problem is how he gets there.

He begins by explaining that the whole alpha male idea rests on a bad reading of animal behavior, then offers his own definition of what makes a man an alpha or a beta. If the foundation for those labels was wrong, why keep the labels? And why hand them new meanings based on one man's opinions?

Replacing One Definition With Another

The article opens with L. David Mech, whose 1970 book helped popularize the alpha wolf. Later research, including Mech's own, showed that picture was mostly wrong. Wild wolf packs are families, with parents guiding their offspring, not unrelated wolves fighting for dominance.

That's a fair correction, and I have no problem admitting we got something wrong and fixing it. The author says as much:

Remember first that the definition itself is wrong. You cannot build anything sound on a faulty foundation.

I agree completely, which is why what comes next confuses me. Having said the popular alpha and beta idea is built on a faulty premise, he goes on to explain what an alpha male really is.

By his account, an alpha is confident, patient, kind, headstrong, and emotionally secure. A beta lacks confidence, maybe through inexperience or lack of ability. Where does that come from? Not from the wolf research. Nothing in wolf behavior says a confident man goes in one bin and an insecure man in another.

As far as I can tell, he took the qualities he admires in men and stuck them on the same labels he had just discredited. I admire confidence, patience, and kindness too. But admiring something doesn't make it the definition of masculinity, and it sure doesn't make it science.

He threw out one shaky definition and put in another that happens to match his own beliefs. The hierarchy is still there. He just changed who sits at the top.

Sorting Men Is Still Sorting Men

The popular version says an alpha is dominant, assertive, and never submits, while a beta is weak, insecure, and indecisive. The author's version says the alpha is emotionally mature, compassionate, and quietly confident, while the beta is still the man who lacks confidence and direction. The vocabulary got nicer. Men are still being divided into better and worse, and a handful of personality traits still decide which is which.

I'm sixty years old, and I've known enough people to know they don't fit in boxes like these. A man can be sure of himself at work and a wreck in his personal relationships. He can be a terrific father and a lousy husband. He can be a good leader who second-guesses every decision, or a decent, responsible guy with no interest in being assertive.

Which box do those men go in? And why should they have to go in one?

Confidence isn't a permanent trait. It shifts with the circumstances, the people, the years. I've been confident in situations where others struggled, and insecure in situations where someone else seemed perfectly at ease. That didn't make me an alpha on Tuesday and a beta on Wednesday.

The more conditions you attach to these labels, the less they tell you. They stop describing people and start grading them.

Who Gets to Decide What Makes a Man?

This is my biggest problem with the article. Who decides what a man is supposed to be, and why should the rest of us go along?

Men have been asked to be warriors, providers, protectors, fathers, leaders, workers, thinkers, and plenty more. Some of those expectations made sense in their time. Others were restrictive, contradictory, or flat-out ridiculous.

Today we're told to be confident but not arrogant, assertive but not controlling, emotionally available but not needy, strong but not intimidating, independent but attentive to everyone else's needs.

None of that is wrong by itself, and a lot of it fits together fine. The trouble starts when someone decides their particular mix is the right way to be a man and begins measuring everybody else against it.

I have no problem with encouraging men to be better people. I do have a problem with the idea that masculinity itself needs constant correcting, redefining, and adjusting to whatever someone currently finds acceptable.

A man who struggles with confidence isn't less of a man. A man who has trouble talking about his feelings isn't weak. Someone who prefers cooperating to leading isn't lacking anything, and someone with plenty of confidence isn't admirable just for that. I've met plenty of confident assholes over the years, and the confidence didn't make them any better.

Men are individuals, with different personalities, strengths, flaws, and histories. I don't see why we need another list of rules telling us which men count as the better kind, especially when the list comes down to one person's preferences.

And What Was That About Feminism?

Another part of the article struck me as odd. The author calls the dominant alpha male the mirror image of extreme feminism, then never says what he means.

Feminism covers a wide range of ideas about men and women. I agree with some, disagree with some, and think some deserve harsh criticism. But tossing out "extreme feminism" as the female version of an aggressive, domineering man says nothing unless you name the beliefs or behaviors you're comparing.

What interests me more is what he does next. Having waved off extreme feminism in a sentence, he spends the rest of the article on what's wrong with certain kinds of men and what makes a better one.

It's an article about masculinity, so I don't expect equal time for women, and I'm not accusing him of holding men and women to different standards. But it points at something bigger. We've gotten comfortable with the idea that masculinity is a problem to be fixed. Men are constantly told what makes them strong, what makes them weak, what makes them attractive, and what makes them problematic. Even when the intentions are good, it usually ends up as one more list of the ways men fall short.

And most of these traits aren't masculine to begin with. Women can be confident or insecure, compassionate or cruel, patient or impulsive, mature or immature, responsible or not. These are human traits. I don't understand why we keep filing them under masculinity as if they measure a man's worth.

I do think there are real differences between men and women, and I see no reason to pretend otherwise. But admitting that doesn't mean one sex's traits make people better or worse than the other's.

If kindness, emotional maturity, patience, and responsibility are admirable, shouldn't they be admirable in everyone? Why turn them into requirements for being a certain kind of man instead of just qualities we value in people?

Strength Isn't Always What Someone Else Thinks It Is

One more line in the article deserves a closer look:

A stronger person would guide you out of your misery. If he cannot, he will walk away.

I see what he's getting at. Helping someone through a hard stretch can be admirable, and knowing when to walk away takes judgment. But neither one proves strength.

Sometimes walking away is the mature thing to do. Other times it's an easy way out of something uncomfortable. Staying can show compassion and commitment, or it can mean sitting in a situation that's doing neither person any good. It depends on the circumstances, and no single response is always the strong one.

The same goes for emotional restraint. Refusing to let someone goad you into doing something stupid is worth something. But sometimes it takes real strength to stand your ground, show anger, admit you're struggling, or ask for help.

I've known quiet, reserved men who were remarkably strong, and loud, confrontational men who were just as strong. Some people handle hard times by keeping it all inside, and others have to talk it out. Neither tells me who has more character.

The author has a particular picture of strength in mind, and he's entitled to it. It isn't the universal standard, and men shouldn't be sorted by how closely they match it.

Maybe It's Time to Retire Alpha and Beta Entirely

Near the end, the author suggests his revised version of alpha and beta is the only one that can change a person's life. That's a bold claim from someone who started by warning against building on a faulty foundation.

I think I see what he's after. Aggression isn't strength, intimidation doesn't earn respect, confidence doesn't give you license to treat people like shit, and kindness isn't weakness. I agree with every bit of that. I just don't see why we need alpha and beta to say it.

Why not simply say that confidence, kindness, responsibility, and emotional maturity are good things to build in yourself? Why turn them into a ranking that sorts men into superior and inferior?

A man can build confidence without becoming an alpha, and he can struggle with insecurity without becoming a beta. He can be kind, assertive, vulnerable, independent, compassionate, stubborn, and sometimes a complete pain in the ass, and none of it says how masculine he is. Women are every bit as complicated, which makes assigning these traits to categories even more pointless.

We've gotten so used to reducing people to fashionable stereotypes that we forget how little the labels tell us. We want an easy way to sort people, then act as if the sorting explains their worth, their character, or their place in the world.

I'm sixty years old. I've been a soldier, a husband, a father, a musician, and a working man. I've made good decisions and some spectacularly bad ones. I've had successes and failures, moments of confidence, and plenty of moments when I wasn't nearly as sure of myself as I would have liked. I've been strong when I had to be, and there were times I wasn't strong at all.

I haven't got everything figured out, and I won't pretend I do. I have my weaknesses, insecurities, opinions, and shortcomings like everybody else. Some I've worked on, some I've learned to live with, and some I'm still chewing on.

None of that makes me an alpha or a beta. It makes me a man who has lived a life, learned a few things, made his share of mistakes, and still has plenty left to figure out.

I don't need someone else's definition of masculinity to tell me what kind of man I am, and I don't see why any other man should either.

#alpha male #confidence #feminism #gender roles #gender stereotypes #individuality #masculinity #men #society #strength #thoughts